Read the original article here.

---

The Universal Media Disc (UMD): A Case Study in Tech Failure

The history of technology is littered with ambitious projects that, for various reasons, failed to achieve widespread, lasting success. The Universal Media Disc (UMD), developed by Sony for its PlayStation Portable (PSP) handheld console, stands out as a prominent example in the realm of physical media formats. While integral to the PSP's initial success, the UMD format itself ultimately proved to be a proprietary misstep that couldn't compete with established formats or adapt to the shift towards digital distribution.

This resource explores the Universal Media Disc, its design, its uses, and the factors that contributed to its eventual discontinuation, positioning it as a case study in the challenges of launching a new media format.

What Was the Universal Media Disc?

The Universal Media Disc (UMD) was a discontinued optical disc medium created by Sony. Its primary purpose was to serve as the physical storage format for games and multimedia content on the PlayStation Portable (PSP), a handheld gaming and entertainment system launched by Sony in 2004.

Optical Disc Medium: A storage medium that uses a laser to read or write data on a disc. Examples include CDs, DVDs, Blu-rays, and UMDs. They store data as patterns of tiny bumps (pits) and flat areas (lands) on the disc surface.

UMD discs were housed within a protective plastic cartridge, distinguishing them physically from open discs like CDs or DVDs. This design was intended to protect the delicate disc surface, especially important for a portable device.

Optical Disc Cartridge (ODC): A case or shell that encloses an optical disc, providing physical protection. The UMD is an example of an ODC.

Technical Specifications and Design

The UMD was a small, robust-looking disc designed specifically for the rigors of portable use.

• Dimensions: Approximately 64 mm in diameter and 4.2 mm thick. The protective case added to the overall dimensions for handling and storage (approx. 177×104×14mm for the case).
• Capacity:
  • Single-layer: Up to 900 megabytes (MB)
  • Dual-layer: Up to 1.80 gigabytes (GB) This capacity was relatively high for a portable format at the time, allowing for significant game data, full-length movies, or large music compilations.
• Laser Technology: It used a 660 nm red laser for reading data. This was similar to the technology used in DVDs, offering higher data density than the infrared lasers used in CDs.
• Optical Properties:
  • Numerical Aperture: 0.64 (A measure of the lens's ability to gather light and focus the laser spot).
  • Track Pitch: 0.70 μm (The distance between consecutive data tracks on the disc).
  • Minimum Pit Length: 0.1384 μm (The smallest recorded feature on the disc, representing data).
• Data Encoding & Error Correction: Employed 8-to-16 modulation with RLL(2,10) coding for efficient data storage and retrieval.
• Security: Included AES 128-bit encryption for copy protection and to ensure content was played back on authorized devices (primarily the PSP).

Red Laser (660 nm): A type of laser used in various optical storage formats (like DVD and UMD) to read and write data. Its shorter wavelength compared to infrared lasers (like those in CDs) allows for smaller data pits and thus higher storage density.

Encryption (AES 128-bit): A standard method of securing digital data by converting it into an unreadable format (ciphertext) that can only be decoded by someone with the correct key. In the context of UMD, it was used to prevent unauthorized copying or playback.

Provisions for Future Development

According to industry standards (ECMA-365), Sony designed the UMD with potential future enhancements in mind, suggesting they initially envisioned a lifespan beyond the initial PSP model or perhaps even use in other devices. These provisions included:

1. Protective Shutter: A planned sliding mechanism, similar to those on MiniDiscs or 3.5-inch floppy disks, that would automatically cover the disc surface when the cartridge was removed from the drive, offering further protection against dust and scratches. This feature was not implemented in the final UMD design used with the PSP.
2. Auto-Loading: The physical design of the UMD cartridge was intended to be compatible with potential future slot-loading drive mechanisms, making insertion and ejection smoother and more robust than tray-loading designs.

The fact that these features were designed for but never implemented highlights either a change in design philosophy during development or a lack of investment in expanding the UMD format beyond its initial application.

Content and Use Cases

The UMD format was primarily developed for PlayStation Portable video games, which constituted the vast majority of its releases throughout the PSP's life cycle. However, Sony also promoted the UMD as a multimedia format, capable of storing and playing back other types of digital content.

Video Content

UMD was positioned as a portable video player format. Major film studios initially released feature-length films on UMD, hoping to capitalize on PSP owners wanting to watch movies on the go.

• Video Encoding: Video was typically encoded using the H.264/MPEG-4 AVC codec, a highly efficient compression standard that allowed relatively high-quality video to fit within the UMD's capacity.
• Audio Encoding: Audio was stored using either ATRAC3plus (Sony's proprietary audio format designed for compression) or PCM (uncompressed audio).
• Resolution: While the source video was often encoded at resolutions up to 720×480 (DVD standard definition), it was scaled down to the PSP's native screen resolution of 480×272 pixels for playback.
• Examples: Around 1,500 films were released worldwide on UMD. Examples included popular movies, television shows (like BBC programs The Office, Doctor Who), music video compilations (The Offspring, Tupac), and even wrestling content (WWE).
• Adult Films: Notably, some adult film studios in Japan also released content on UMD. This caused some controversy, with Sony reportedly expressing disapproval but claiming technical inability to restrict such content on the format, unlike how they could control game releases.

H.264/MPEG-4 AVC: A widely used industry standard for video compression known for its high efficiency. It allows video to be stored and transmitted using significantly less bandwidth or storage space compared to uncompressed formats, while maintaining good visual quality.

ATRAC3plus / PCM: ATRAC3plus was a proprietary audio compression format developed by Sony. PCM (Pulse-Code Modulation) is an uncompressed, standard digital audio format. Offering both options provided flexibility – ATRAC3plus for saving space, and PCM for potentially higher fidelity audio (though at the cost of much larger file sizes).

Resolution Scaling: The process of resizing a video image to fit a different screen resolution. Encoding video at 720x480 on UMD meant it had more detail than the PSP screen could display, requiring the PSP to shrink the image down, potentially losing some sharpness but ensuring compatibility with the source format.

Music Content

While less common than games or movies, a limited number of music albums or compilations were also released on UMD.

Region Coding

Similar to DVDs, most UMD movies and music releases incorporated region coding. This is a digital rights management technique used to control the distribution and release dates of content across different geographical areas.

Region Coding: A system used for optical discs like DVDs and UMDs to prevent discs purchased in one geographical region from being played on devices sold in another region. This allows content distributors to control release windows, pricing, and content variations by territory.

The UMD region codes mirrored those used for DVD:

• Region ALL: Worldwide (Region-free)
• Region 1: North America, Central America, Latin America
• Region 2: Europe (excluding Russia, Belarus), Japan, Middle East, South Africa, Greenland
• Region 3: Southeast Asia, Taiwan, South Korea, Hong Kong
• Region 4: Oceania, South America
• Region 5: Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, India, Pakistan, Africa (excluding Egypt, South Africa), North Korea, Mongolia
• Region 6: China

Crucially, all PSP games released on UMD were region-free, meaning a game bought in Japan could be played on a PSP from Europe or North America. This contrast between region-free games and region-locked multimedia highlighted Sony's differing priorities and business models for the two types of content.

The Decline and Failure of UMD

Despite its technical capabilities and initial adoption alongside the popular PSP, the UMD format ultimately failed to establish itself as a sustainable media format beyond its dedicated gaming purpose. Several factors contributed to its decline, marking it as a significant tech failure:

1. Proprietary and Limited Ecosystem: UMD was exclusively tied to the PlayStation Portable. Unlike CDs or DVDs, there were no UMD writers available to consumers or third parties, meaning the format could only be used for pre-recorded content produced by authorized manufacturers. This closed ecosystem severely limited its potential applications and user adoption outside of official releases.

   Proprietary Format: A technology standard or format that is owned and controlled by a single company, restricting its use, development, or manufacturing by others without a license. This contrasts with open standards.

2. High Cost of Media Releases: UMD movies and TV shows were often priced similarly to their DVD counterparts, sometimes even higher. However, they frequently lacked the bonus features, commentary tracks, and higher resolution offered by DVDs. Consumers perceived poor value compared to established formats, especially given the smaller screen of the PSP.

3. Lack of Industry Support: Early poor sales of UMD movies led major studios like Universal and Paramount to withdraw their support relatively quickly. This severely limited the availability of video content, making the format less attractive for its multimedia capabilities. Similarly, retail stores like Wal-Mart began phasing out shelf space for UMD movies, further hindering availability.

4. Sony's Internal Shift: Sensing the industry-wide trend towards digital distribution, Sony began to pivot away from physical media, even for its own gaming platform.

   • Push to PlayStation Network (PSN): Sony encouraged developers to release games digitally via the PlayStation Store (PSN) as an alternative to UMD.
   • PSP Go (2009): Sony launched the PSP Go model, which famously omitted the UMD drive entirely, relying solely on digital downloads from PSN. This move alienated consumers who had existing UMD collections and highlighted Sony's waning commitment to the physical format. The PSP Go itself saw lackluster sales compared to UMD-compatible models, demonstrating that while Sony was ready to move on, a significant portion of the user base was not.

5. Successor Format Abandonment: The PlayStation Vita, the successor to the PSP, did not include a UMD drive or any form of UMD compatibility. It adopted a new, flash-based proprietary cartridge format for physical releases and placed a strong emphasis on digital downloads, sealing the UMD's fate.

End of the Line

The combination of limited external support, consumer reluctance due to pricing and value, and Sony's internal strategic shift towards digital distribution led to the rapid decline of UMD outside of its core PSP gaming function.

• UMD movie releases effectively ended around 2011.
• UMD game releases continued a bit longer, with the last games published on the format appearing around 2013.
• Physical production of UMDs ceased when the last manufacturing plant producing them closed in late 2016.

While UMD served its purpose for the lifespan of the PSP as a gaming medium, its failure as a broader multimedia format, due to its proprietary nature, cost, and Sony's own strategic changes, positions it as a classic example of a format that couldn't adapt or compete in the rapidly evolving tech landscape. The inability to write data to UMDs, the lack of compatibility with other devices, and the inconvenient transition away from the format (exemplified by the PSP Go) contributed significantly to its narrative as a technology that, while functional, ultimately failed to gain widespread acceptance or longevity.

---